Puzzlement

'The mind has mountains,
cliffs of fall,
sheer no-man-fathomed...'

Gerard Manley Hopkins

Some lives are ended, others just end.

Some deaths make sense; others stun reason

and make minds bend.

Death's a dark gate somewhere unseen

which springs shocking surprise when sudden

but which, when bidden,

delivers definite deletion.

Of the latter the sense lies

in the mercy sought or

in the justice demanded:

a plea for rescue from unacceptable pain

or a rage to remove intolerable evil.

It's when death's gate opens unbidden

when one is caught in the clutch of chance

('accident') that death offends,

morphing from mercy to menace.

In such a death the mind gropes

for meaning, flings grappling hooks

up sheer cliffs one is desperate

to climb up out of.

Deep down its crater

the heart calls out but

no answers come,

only echoes of the cry.

Bereft, what is one to do?

Speak out now, let loose rage

lest it churns currents in caverns

inside the self? before sorrow floods

the basin and burst its chambers?

Or just sit still and be,

aware and wakeful, holding steady,

girded and all for this

dark night's journey of the soul?

Will the time come for answers

to fill the void and bring to heart

love's peace and to mind

its calming balm?

Isn't there a nagging doubt

that all this is but wishful thought,

casting about, seeking anchors afloat

after a loved one's life, sorry to say,

comes to naught?

A senseless death stirs these questions.

The heart is hurt, the mind muddled:

A beloved presence is gone;

a life's work's undone.

One strives to bury griefs;

remembrance is a pledge.

That one will understand and accept

who is to tell, who the sage?

Old prophet Job, you were buffeted too.

What say you of this damn, dumb

puzzlement?